In partnership with
Television is incestuous. Every prestige drama is a sitcom’s bastard child, every reality show has a soap opera godparent, and sometimes a cartoon rabbit is secretly raising your favourite feminist antihero. TV doesn’t evolve in straight lines — it cannibalises itself, mutates, and dresses the same archetypes in new costumes. That’s where Unhinged TV Family Trees comes in.
There’s a theory — half serious, half delirious — that every teen show since the 90s is just a remix of Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Sometimes it’s obvious (Charmed, Teen Wolf, Riverdale). Sometimes it’s hiding in plain sight, under sequins and auto-tune. Which brings us to the unhinged but undeniable truth: without Buffy, there would be no Glee.
Yes, one had vampires and hellmouths and Sarah Michelle Gellar with a crossbow. The other had a show choir, slushies, and Lea Michele with a Broadway belt. But structurally? Tonally? Spiritually? They are the same show. Both monster-of-the-week. Both ensembles of misfits. Both deeply camp in ways they pretended not to be. And both understood that high school itself is the apocalypse.
Sunnydale High vs. McKinley High
Let’s start with setting. Buffy’s Sunnydale High was literally built on a Hellmouth — a portal to evil that manifested weekly as new demons, vampires, and curses. Glee’s McKinley High might as well have been sitting on a Hellmouth too, given how many crises manifested every Tuesday at 8pm. One week: Buffy battling a puppet possessed by a demon. One week: Rachel and Kurt battling for a Barbra Streisand solo. Different monsters, same episodic rhythm.
The point wasn’t the monster or the ballad. The point was what it revealed about the characters — their insecurities, their relationships, their survival tactics. Buffy’s were literal life-and-death; Glee’s were social life-and-death. Either way, adolescence was dramatized as a series of trials by fire (or by Journey).
The Scooby Gang and the Glee Club
Both shows were about outcasts forming a family when the world refused them one. Buffy’s Scooby Gang — Willow, Xander, Giles, later Spike, Faith, Anya — weren’t the chosen ones, they were the ones who chose each other. Same with the Glee Club. Finn, Rachel, Kurt, Mercedes, Artie — all people shoved to the sidelines who found power in numbers.
And in both shows, friendship was survival. No one saved Sunnydale alone. No one won Nationals alone. Every week was a test of loyalty, of whether the group would hold. And every week, they pulled together just in time to slay the demon or nail the key change.
Camp, Sincerity, and the Monster Musical
Here’s where the comparison gets spookily literal. In 2001, Buffy gave us “Once More, With Feeling,” the musical episode that proved television could turn camp melodrama into high art. Every emotion — longing, fear, love, trauma — was heightened through song. The episode didn’t just break TV; it rewrote what teen storytelling could do.
Eight years later, Glee launched by building an entire empire on that same conceit: the musical as catharsis. Every week, emotions became spectacle. Songs weren’t just filler; they were the plot. Rachel singing “Don’t Rain on My Parade” was Buffy belting “Going Through the Motions,” just with less vampire dust and more jazz hands.
And let’s not forget: Joss Whedon himself literally directed an episode of Glee. That’s not metaphorical DNA. That’s direct lineage.
Buffy’s Metaphors, Glee’s Melodrama
Where Buffy used monsters as metaphors for teen trauma — high school is hell, literally — Glee used melodrama. Every fight, every solo, every slushie in the face was just as heightened as a vampire attack. When Buffy lost her mother, it shattered viewers. When Santana came out, it cracked open closets across America. Different stakes, same emotional engine.
Both shows understood teenagers as creatures of extremity. Love was apocalyptic. Loss was world-ending. A kiss could save your life. A breakup could kill you. Camp and sincerity coexisted in the same frame, because that’s what adolescence feels like: ridiculous and devastating, at the same time.
Why the Queer Kids Knew It First
Queer audiences, of course, clocked this connection immediately. Buffy gave us Willow and Tara, one of the first openly queer couples on network TV — not a very special episode, not a tragedy in waiting, but a relationship that was simply allowed to exist across seasons, woven into the fabric of the show. Glee gave us Kurt and Blaine, a queer romance staged not in whispers but in duets, performed in front of the whole school, the whole country, on prime time television. Both shows told us: the monsters aren't you, they're outside you. And also: sometimes the monster is your own longing, your own hunger, your own refusal to stay in the box the world built for you.
I watched both shows at the wrong age for the wrong reasons and understood them completely anyway. That's the thing about camp — it speaks sideways. It lets you receive the emotional truth without having to name what you're receiving. Buffy wasn't about vampires. Glee wasn't about show choir. They were about surviving the particular cruelty of being too much, or not enough, or simply different, in an institution designed to grind difference out of you. Queer kids have always been fluent in that language, because we've always had to be.
Both shows did it with exaggeration, with excess, with the unapologetic decision to treat teenage feelings as mythic. The queerness was never just in the characters. It was in the sensibility. The sequins. The stakes. The absolute refusal to be subtle about how much any of it mattered.
Same Apocalypse, Different Soundtrack
So yes, Buffy fought demons while Glee fought mashups. One had stakings, one had slushies. But both were monster-of-the-week teen operas that turned growing up into a spectacle of survival. They taught us that high school was always a battlefield — whether you were dodging vampires in the graveyard or dodging Cheerios in the hallway.
Without Buffy, Glee would never have existed. It inherited the structure, the tone, the camp, even the director. One gave us the apocalypse in a graveyard. The other gave us the apocalypse in a show choir riser. Same battle. Different weapons.
Because in the end, Buffy gave us demons. Glee gave us “Don’t Stop Believin’.” Same apocalypse. Different soundtrack.